ALBUQUERQUE, United States — A New Mexico judge has dismissed child sexual abuse charges against Hollywood actor Timothy Busfield, citing misconduct by prosecutors during grand jury proceedings.
Busfield, 69, who appeared in The West Wing and Field of Dreams, had faced four felony charges involving allegations that he inappropriately touched two boys while directing a television series.
State District Judge Joseph Montano dismissed the indictment on Friday, October 16, 2026, after finding that prosecutors had failed to conduct the grand jury proceedings fairly.
The ruling does not prevent authorities from seeking a new indictment.
Prosecutors said they were reviewing the decision and had not determined whether to bring the charges again, according to The Associated Press.
Busfield has consistently denied the allegations.
Judge Finds Misconduct in Grand Jury Proceedings
The judge’s decision followed a challenge by Busfield’s lawyers, who accused prosecutors of withholding potentially favourable evidence and preventing grand jurors from hearing witnesses they had specifically requested.
The defence argued that several witnesses were available to testify but were not permitted to appear before the grand jury.
Lawyers also accused prosecutors of incorrectly explaining the rules governing evidence, including the admissibility of polygraph results.
According to TMZ, Montano found that prosecutors had misrepresented evidentiary rules and failed to arrange testimony requested by grand jurors.
He concluded that the prosecution had not acted fairly or impartially, undermining the integrity of the indictment process.
During a September hearing, the defence played recordings of grand jurors requesting additional witnesses.
Prosecutor Greer Staley disputed the misconduct allegations, arguing that Busfield’s lawyers had not followed proper procedures for presenting evidence.
Staley also accused the defence of trying to steer grand jurors toward favourable testimony.
The judge ultimately accepted the challenge to the indictment.
Allegations Involved Two Child Actors
The case arose from allegations involving twin boys who appeared in The Cleaning Lady, a television drama filmed in Albuquerque between 2022 and 2024.
Their parents accused Busfield, who worked as a director and producer on the programme, of inappropriate physical contact with the children.
The allegations surfaced after the production removed the boys.
Busfield surrendered to police in January and was subsequently released pending trial.
A grand jury indicted him in February on four counts of criminal sexual contact with a child under 13.
His lawyers maintained that the allegations were fabricated and alleged that the children’s parents had encouraged false accusations after the boys lost their roles.
The defence also cited initial police interviews in which the children reportedly denied inappropriate contact.
Busfield personally rejected the allegations while testifying before the grand jury.
“I’m saying that is absolutely one gazillion percent untrue. Never ever,” he said.
The actor, who is married to actress Melissa Gilbert, also told jurors that the accusations had damaged his career and family life.
He said he had lost professional opportunities and been dropped by his talent agency.





